Compare
Athlete head-to-head
Compare career records, current form and shared race results. Use athlete slugs, names, or profile IDs.
Battle read
Melanie Mc Quaid leads the stored head-to-head
Last 5 shared: Sarah Karpinski 2, Melanie Mc Quaid 3. This only counts races where both athletes have stored results.
Win share
Sarah Karpinski
27%
Win share
Melanie Mc Quaid
73%
Latest shared race
2025 Ironman Arizona
11/15/2025 · edge Melanie Mc Quaid
22
Sarah Karpinski
21
Melanie Mc Quaid
Head-to-head
Sarah Karpinski vs Melanie Mc Quaid
Melanie Mc Quaid leads: 3-8 across 11 shared starts
Last 5 shared: Sarah Karpinski 2, Melanie Mc Quaid 3
Latest shared race: 2025 Ironman Arizona - edge Melanie Mc Quaid
Career starts: Sarah Karpinski 35, Melanie Mc Quaid 64
Career wins: Sarah Karpinski 0, Melanie Mc Quaid 2
35
Starts
64
0
Wins
2
0
Podiums
8
5
Top 10s
33
#7
Best
#1
#15.4
Avg pos
#10.1
671
Points
2104
3
Sarah Karpinski head-to-head wins
11
Shared race starts
8
Melanie Mc Quaid head-to-head wins
Shared races
Only races where both athletes have a stored result are shown.
2025 Ironman Arizona
11/15/2025
22
Sarah Karpinski
10:08:30
21
Melanie Mc Quaid
10:03:02
2025 Ironman Chattanooga
9/27/2025
12
Sarah Karpinski
10:04:32
DNF
Melanie Mc Quaid
DNF
2025 Ironman 70.3 Oceanside
4/4/2025
29
Sarah Karpinski
5:37:52
17
Melanie Mc Quaid
4:44:03
2024 Ironman Chattanooga
9/28/2024
20
Sarah Karpinski
3:36:05
DNF
Melanie Mc Quaid
DNF
2023 Ironman Coeur d'Alene
6/24/2023
11
Sarah Karpinski
10:31:45
3
Melanie Mc Quaid
9:22:02
2022 Ironman Wisconsin
9/10/2022
10
Sarah Karpinski
11:09:40
3
Melanie Mc Quaid
10:06:34
2022 Ironman Lake Placid
7/23/2022
13
Sarah Karpinski
10:38:41
5
Melanie Mc Quaid
9:34:31
2022 Ironman 70.3 Oceanside
4/1/2022
25
Sarah Karpinski
4:52:32
15
Melanie Mc Quaid
4:33:57
2021 Ironman 70.3 Timberman
8/21/2021
20
Sarah Karpinski
4:59:32
22
Melanie Mc Quaid
5:03:26
2019 Ironman 70.3 Waco
10/26/2019
12
Sarah Karpinski
4:52:47
4
Melanie Mc Quaid
4:28:51
2019 Ironman Wisconsin
9/7/2019
8
Sarah Karpinski
10:53:48
2
Melanie Mc Quaid
9:29:17
| Race | Sarah Karpinski | Melanie Mc Quaid | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 Ironman Arizona 11/15/2025 | 22 10:08:30 | 21 10:03:02 | B |
| 2025 Ironman Chattanooga 9/27/2025 | 12 10:04:32 | DNF DNF | A |
| 2025 Ironman 70.3 Oceanside 4/4/2025 | 29 5:37:52 | 17 4:44:03 | B |
| 2024 Ironman Chattanooga 9/28/2024 | 20 3:36:05 | DNF DNF | A |
| 2023 Ironman Coeur d'Alene 6/24/2023 | 11 10:31:45 | 3 9:22:02 | B |
| 2022 Ironman Wisconsin 9/10/2022 | 10 11:09:40 | 3 10:06:34 | B |
| 2022 Ironman Lake Placid 7/23/2022 | 13 10:38:41 | 5 9:34:31 | B |
| 2022 Ironman 70.3 Oceanside 4/1/2022 | 25 4:52:32 | 15 4:33:57 | B |
| 2021 Ironman 70.3 Timberman 8/21/2021 | 20 4:59:32 | 22 5:03:26 | A |
| 2019 Ironman 70.3 Waco 10/26/2019 | 12 4:52:47 | 4 4:28:51 | B |
| 2019 Ironman Wisconsin 9/7/2019 | 8 10:53:48 | 2 9:29:17 | B |